Joe Lovano: Trio Tapestry

I used to keep listening journals and on a raining Sunday afternoon I resurrected it. And while the blog has been asleep for a while, I decided to post it here.

Joe Lovano: Trio Tapestry & Garden of Expression (ECM)
Joe Lovano (tenor sax/soprano sax/taragato/gongs) Marilyn Crispell (piano) Carmine Castaldi (drums/percussion)

I've kept an ear on Joe Lovano over years and I usually check out his work when the other personnel are of interest. And it was the presence of Marilyn Crispell that drew my attention to Trio Tapestry as over the last few years I have been increasingly enjoying her music.

Recorded in 2019 and released this year, Garden of Expression is the second album from Trio Tapestry. I was excited when the first (Trio Tapestry) was released but it didn’t strike me at the time… something must have stuck with me though, as I didn’t hesitate grabbing the second release.

The album touches on some areas that have been of interest to me for a while that I want to explore in my music - especially space, and silence - these are some of the same qualities that struck me when hearing Evan Parker’s 2016 release As The Wind (PSI) as well as some of Hayden Chisholm's work.

“Chapel Song” opens the album with a light, crystal, brightness that becomes increasingly warm while retaining the lightness. A delicate piano intro sets the tone for “Night Creatures”. It is interesting to hear what a prominent role the cymbals have on the sound and feel of both of these albums. Overall the drum texture really works for me. Often understated and unafraid of space or backing off. The piano gets busy under some melodic tenor....it works though. Ending is somewhat abrupt. The tracks are longer on this album than the first - not overly so (between 3- 7 1.2 mins with one sitting at almost 11), although there are 3 fewer pieces. “West of the Moon” has a nice flow to it – gentle swells. I like the change in “Garden of Expression” following the opening as it shifts into being momentary more rhythmically unsettled before returning to the warm melody. The piano and drums really lock in through the piano “solo”... really more of a piano/drum dialogue (with some nicely time gong hits from Lovano). The piece moves through many moods before returning home. My ears immediately pricked up as Lovano entered “Treasured Moments”, the vibrato and intonation bring a strangely wonderful tension – settled and unsettled at the same time. Economy is key here. It leads wonderfully into “Sacred Chant” which has a relaxed, joyous sound. The piece ends and feels unfinished. Piano and drums lead off on “Dream on That”, before the piano makes way for the tenor, and then then trio all together. Although this tune features a couple of duets, there’s more of everyone playing together on this album. Something I enjoyed with Trio Tapestry is the way the trio is broken up - solos, duos and trio. On Garden of Expression the sound of the trio is more present. Whereas Trio Tapestry ends with one of the more outwardly intense pieces, Garden of Expression comes back to space with “Zen Like”. It’s my favourite track on the album. Unhurried. Space. A weightless quality. Dig it.

Listening to Garden of Expression led me to revisit Trio Tapestry, and I’m enjoying it a lot more this time around. It still doesn’t quite hit the spot the way Garden of Expression does, but it has grown on me a lot since my last listen (although I'm still not sure what ECM were thinking with that cover art!).

Opening with gongs and cymbals before the tenor enters - I’m struck by the blend between the gongs and the tenor. “One Time In” acts as a spacious prelude. The trio are there from beat one of “Seeds of Change”. Unsurprisingly the sound is denser. The playing remains economical but the sense of space has changed. The piece feels longer. It is, but remains concise. “Razzle Dazzle” opens with solo piano with both hands in unison as drums creep in. The difference in space between one, two, and three active players is evident. Crispell’s piano lines behind the tenor bring to mind the opening phrase. “Sparkle Lights” opens with tenor and piano together before giving way to traded phrases that merge in places while the drums remains sparse. The longest track is “Mystic” (pieces range between 2 and 8 1/2 mins). A quiet rumble of drums is greeted by Lovano on tarogato. Space is at the fore. The rumbling swells but the space and sparse tarogato lines remain, eventually replaced by gong sounds. Eventually the piece builds into a more tradition duo between drums and tarogato. This may be my favourite piece on the album (which is mildly amusing as Crispell lays out). “Piano/Drum Episode” is as it suggests. Piano notes ring out and decay. The drumming is subtle with a warm cushioning quality that is perhaps interrupted by the bass drum. The cymbal hit at the end is all about timing and finding just the right spot. “Gong Episode” is just that – two minutes of gongs. It is well placed in the album flow. “Rare Beauty” opens with full trio, the dynamics are raised and there is a sense of urgency – perhaps heightened following the nature of the gong piece. Lovely interplay between the lines in each hand of the piano. Some of the busier playing on the album... but everyone else drops out to maintain balance. Lovano enters on tenor with Castaldi swinging quietly mid-tempo. The return of piano to take the tune out feels a bit abrupt. “Spirit Lake” opens with drums and tenor. I’m enjoying Castaldi’s stick work at low volume. The piano entry here works much better than the previous track. More dense playing than previously hear - rippling piano, tenor flurries with some growls and altissimo, and busier playing from the drums. “Tarrassa” opens with solo piano. The tenor enters with the drums – and the drum phrasing is standing out to me during this three-way dialogue. Creative playing without overdoing it. The album had been building in density and I was expected the closing piece - “The Smiling Dog” - might see a return to the quiet spaces present in the first half of the album. But it doesn’t and it leaves things feeling somewhat unresolved.

So these two albums have been getting a decent amount of airtime and I feel listening to Garden of Expression opened up Trio Tapestry for me. Lovano has selected the personnel wisely and I hope this group stays together.